Talk:List of staff (XC1)

XC3D/DE/FC staff
How should we treat the staff of the rereleases and Future Connected? I see these options:
 * 1) All games share the same article and the same space (would be pretty messy)
 * 2) Same as above, but Future Connected is separate
 * 3) Make 3D/DE/FC a different section on the same article
 * 4) Make 3D/DE/FC different articles, but link to the XC1 article for original staff (makes sense since the entire original staff is just compiled in a "Special Thanks" section in DE)
 * 5) Same as above, but copy the entire XC1 staff instead
 * 6) Any of the above, but 3D is on the same article as the Wii version (should be easy since that was entirely done by Monster Games)

Personally, I think option 4+6 is the way to go. Any thoughts? Reggiamoto (talk) 21:46, 21 November 2021 (EST)

Edit: I checked how MarioWiki handles this. They make completely separate articles and copy the "old" staff team, even for fairly similar games like on and. Reggiamoto (talk) 22:03, 21 November 2021 (EST)
 * Are the credits really different enough that this is necessary? I would've expected to be able to list the Wii staff first, followed by a section per rerelease for all the additional people. STM (t) 07:49, 22 November 2021 (EST)
 * There are quite a few differences. The order is different between the two games. Some people are credited differently (such as ACE+ being replaced with ACE and Kenji Hiramatsu with the note "ex ACE+" or Jenna Coleman being credited as "Jenna Louise Coleman" in the Wii version, but not DE). I think it's easier to just keep them separate. Reggiamoto (talk) 18:22, 22 November 2021 (EST)
 * Yeah those sorts of differences are a good argument for duplication. Given that, I think the most logical division is two pages: Wii with 3DS included, and DE with FC included. STM (t) 18:26, 22 November 2021 (EST)
 * There are also regional differences to the 3DS and Wii credits for JP vs Western. I linked recordings of all the different ones in a message on the discord server. Also, MarioWiki copies the order/formatting in game so should we do the same? For Wii this would mean the EN voice actors are at the end while the JP ones are at the beginning. Zachruff (talk) 20:24, 22 November 2021 (EST)