Talk:Solaris

Too short?
When looking at Special:ShortPages, this is the third shortest article on the wiki, only ahead of two disambig articles (that can be ignored). Not only that, but this also has the wrong navbox, and if I remove that, there's literally just one sentence left for a topic that deserves way more than that. The deletion policy states that we shouldn't just delete stubs, but I'd like to question if there is a lower limit in how short it is allowed to be. On Discord we've already discussed how it's probably better to leave a redlink as a redlink if the article doesn't hold any valuable information, and it's not worth increasing the article count if it also increases the stub count. This isn't just a question regarding this one article, but rather if we need to define new rules (or at least give a loose guideline).

By the way, I'd like to expand the article, but it's been a while since I played Xenogears and I'd probably have to rewatch some cutscenes. Reggiamoto (talk) 13:13, 25 March 2021 (EDT)
 * I'm in favour of changing the deletion policy so that stubs are only protected if they have structure. This article has no structure (no infobox, section layout, etc). STM (t) 17:30, 25 March 2021 (EDT)

Continuity Error
In researching this article I found that Perfect Works contains a continuity error with respect to the Miang - Gazel Ministry dynamic during the war that occurred 500 years ago. In the History/Social Structure portion of the book it says that Miang favored other members of humanity over the Gazel to act as the Animus parts for Deus, resulting in the conflict between them. In the Miang character section of the book it states that Miang determined that humanity was not yet ready to be absorbed into Deus, but the Gazel thought otherwise, leading to the conflict between them. It is possible this is a translation error. In any case I've tried to follow what is said in Perfect Works as much as possible, resulting in a discrepancy with what I included on this page versus what is included on the Miang character page. If people have thoughts on how to handle things, feel free to opine. User:Quiddity131